Unlocking the Potential of ESOPs: A Comprehensive Guide for Startups and Employees

In the fast-paced world of startups, attracting and retaining top talent is a challenge that requires a combination of creativity and financial prudence. One of the most effective tools for addressing these challenges is the Employee Stock Ownership Plan (ESOP), which not only gives employees a stake in the company but also aligns their success with the business’s long-term goals. However, for all their benefits, ESOPs are not without complexity. This article aims to break down the key elements of ESOPs, offering actionable advice for startups on structuring them effectively and guiding employees on how to maximize their personal financial outcomes.

What is an ESOP?

At its core, an ESOP is a program that allows employees to acquire shares in the company, usually at a discounted or predetermined price. Unlike traditional compensation models that rely purely on salary and bonuses, ESOPs offer employees ownership in the business, typically through stock options or restricted stock units (RSUs).

The phrase “skin in the game” often gets tossed around when discussing ESOPs, but what does that really mean? For companies, it signals a shift toward a partnership model, where employees are not just workers but shareholders who benefit directly from the company’s growth. For employees, it can mean substantial upside if the company performs well — but it also comes with risks, particularly for startups where success is far from guaranteed.

In essence, an ESOP is about creating alignment. When employees have a financial stake in the company’s success, they are more likely to go above and beyond to ensure its future. This has been proven by companies like Google, Facebook, and Microsoft, where early employees reaped significant rewards from their ESOPs.

Objectives of ESOPs: Why Companies Use Them

Startups typically operate in a cash-constrained environment. High salaries can drain vital resources, especially in the early stages when a company is pre-revenue or barely breaking even. ESOPs offer a solution by allowing companies to conserve cash while still providing meaningful compensation. This can be particularly attractive in industries where top talent is fiercely competitive, such as technology and biotechnology.

However, ESOPs are not just a cash-saving mechanism. They are a strategic tool for rewarding performance and creating a sense of ownership among employees. A well-structured ESOP can have the following key benefits:

• Boosting Retention: One of the main reasons companies introduce ESOPs is to retain employees. Stock options typically vest over a period (commonly four years), meaning employees only fully “own” their shares if they stay with the company for the long haul. This ensures that key employees are less likely to jump ship for another offer, knowing that leaving too soon could mean forfeiting valuable stock options.
• Attracting Top Talent: Especially in highly competitive markets like Silicon Valley, high-growth startups need to be able to attract top-tier talent without breaking the bank. Offering stock options as part of the compensation package can bridge that gap by offering potential for future wealth, even if the starting salary isn’t as high as what might be offered by a more established company.
• Incentivizing Performance: When employees are also shareholders, their goals tend to align more closely with those of the company. This translates to a workforce that is motivated to work toward the company’s success, knowing that their stock options will increase in value as the company grows.
• Wealth Creation: Perhaps the most compelling reason for employees to participate in ESOPs is the potential for substantial financial gain. For example, early employees of Airbnb and Uber saw their stock options turn into millions of dollars once these companies went public. This kind of wealth creation is one of the most appealing aspects of an ESOP, especially for employees at high-growth startups.

How Does an ESOP Work?

While the basic mechanics of an ESOP are straightforward, it’s important to dive deeper into the process of vesting, exercising options, and employee rights. Here’s a step-by-step breakdown:

1. Creation: The company establishes a stock option program, reserving a portion of the equity for the ESOP. This percentage is known as the ESOP pool and typically ranges from 10 to 15 per cent of the company’s total shares. This pool size is critical — it determines how many options the company can grant and affects equity distribution, which may impact future funding rounds.
2. Granting: Once the pool is created, the company grants options to eligible employees. The number of options an employee receives is often based on their role, seniority, and potential impact on the company’s success.
3. Vesting Period: Stock options do not become the employee’s property immediately. Instead, they vest over time, often through a four-year schedule with a one-year cliff. This means employees must work for at least one year to receive any shares at all, and after that, shares vest monthly or annually. This ensures that the employee remains committed to the company for a longer period.
4. Exercise: After options have vested, employees have the right to buy shares at the exercise price (also known as the strike price), which is usually set at the company’s valuation at the time of the grant. If the company has grown significantly, the market price may be much higher than the exercise price, offering employees the opportunity to purchase shares at a discount.
5. Sale: Eventually, employees may decide to sell their shares, either on a secondary market (if the company allows it), through a buyback program, or during a liquidity event like an IPO or acquisition.

It’s essential for employees to understand the implications of each of these steps, particularly when it comes to taxation and the financial commitment involved in exercising options.

Types of Stock Grants: RSUs, Options, and Phantom Shares

Understanding the different types of stock options available is key to making informed decisions as an employee. The most common types include:

• Restricted Stock Units (RSUs): With RSUs, employees are granted company shares after meeting specific vesting conditions. RSUs differ from traditional stock options in that there is typically no exercise price. Once the shares vest, they belong to the employee outright. However, they may still be subject to restrictions, such as being unable to sell until a liquidity event occurs.
• Stock Options: This is the most common type of grant in an ESOP. Employees are given the option to purchase shares at a set price after the vesting period. The key advantage here is that if the company’s valuation increases, employees can exercise their options and buy shares at a lower price, potentially resulting in a significant financial gain. The downside is that stock options can expire if not exercised within a set timeframe.
• Phantom Shares: These are not real shares but are designed to mimic the value of company stock. Employees receive cash bonuses equivalent to the value of a certain number of shares. Phantom shares can be advantageous for companies that want to offer the financial benefits of stock ownership without diluting equity.

Taxation of ESOPs

Tax implications are one of the most important factors for employees to consider. Generally, taxation occurs at two points:

1. At the Time of Exercise: When an employee exercises their stock options, the difference between the exercise price and the fair market value of the shares is considered income and is taxed accordingly. This can be a significant tax burden, especially if the company’s valuation has skyrocketed.
2. At the Time of Sale: Once an employee sells their shares, any profit made is subject to capital gains tax. If the shares are held for over a year, they are taxed at the lower long-term capital gains rate, which can be a key tax advantage.

Tax laws around ESOPs vary greatly from country to country, so employees need to consult with financial and tax professionals to fully understand their obligations. For instance, in the U.S., Incentive Stock Options (ISOs) are taxed differently than Non-Qualified Stock Options (NSOs), with the former potentially offering more favorable tax treatment.

Best Practices for Setting Up ESOPs

Startups need to approach the design and implementation of an ESOP with careful planning. Here are some best practices:

1. Appropriate ESOP Pool: Startups should aim to reserve 10–15 per cent of total equity for the ESOP pool. However, this percentage should be reassessed as the company grows, particularly after major funding rounds. Founders must strike a balance between offering enough equity to attract top talent without excessively diluting their ownership stake.
2. Timing: Setting up the ESOP before significant fundraising rounds is crucial. Once external investors come on board, renegotiating the ESOP pool becomes more complicated, as additional stock options dilute the investors’ equity stakes.
3. Custom Vesting Schedules: While a four-year vesting schedule is common, companies should consider tailoring vesting schedules to specific roles. For example, senior leadership might have a longer vesting period to ensure they remain committed through critical growth phases, while shorter vesting periods can be offered to key hires in high-demand roles.
4. Regular Valuation Updates: As startups scale, the company’s valuation will fluctuate. Regularly updating the company’s valuation ensures that stock grants reflect the company’s current value, helping employees better understand the potential worth of their equity.

Liquidity Opportunities for Employees

The biggest question employees often have about ESOPs is when they can cash in their shares. While ESOPs can offer significant upside, the road to liquidity is often unclear. Here are some common liquidity opportunities:

• Secondary Markets: Some startups allow employees to sell their shares on private secondary markets before the company goes public. This can be an excellent option for employees seeking liquidity without waiting for an IPO or acquisition.
• Buyback Programs: Many companies offer buyback programs, where employees can sell shares back to the company at a predetermined price. This can be especially beneficial for employees who want liquidity but don’t want to wait for a public exit.
• Company Exit: In the event of an IPO or acquisition, employees often have the opportunity to sell their shares. While this is the most lucrative option for many, it also comes with its risks, as the timing of such events is often unpredictable.

Conclusion: ESOPs are a powerful tool for startups and employees alike, offering the potential for financial gain while aligning the interests of the workforce with the company’s success. For companies, they are a critical means of attracting, retaining, and incentivizing talent without straining cash flow. For employees, ESOPs represent an opportunity for wealth creation and a direct stake in the company’s future.

However, ESOPs are not without their challenges. Both companies and employees need to be aware of the complexities around vesting, exercising, and taxation to make the most of this arrangement. With careful planning and execution, ESOPs can be a win-win strategy that drives long-term success for all stakeholders involved.

Thanks to Gagan Singh, CEO of WOWS Global for the insights that allowed to put this article together. WOWS Global is a fintech platform that connects promising startups with investors, facilitating both primary and secondary transactions. A Chartered Accountant by qualification, Gagan began his career in corporate finance with UK-based Vedanta Resources before moving to Southeast Asia to work with Polyplex.

He later became a Partner & CFO at Inspire Ventures, where he played a pivotal role in making strategic investments in companies like aCommerce, Deliveree, Super Awesome, and more. In 2015, Gagan joined the founding team of Deliveree, a leading B2B logistics firm in Southeast Asia, serving as Group CFO and board member. His leadership helped secure over $120 million in funding for the company.

Did you find this article valuable? We can help your business make an impact with professionally crafted content.